
Volume 1 Issue
2 May
28, 2004
Using Reduced Herbicide Rates for Wild Oat Control
Herbicides are registered at application
rates that are adequate for good weed control under a wide
variety of conditions. When conditions are favorable for
herbicide activity, however, lower application rates
(below labeled rates) will often provide good weed control
at a reduced price.
The following are factors to consider when applying
reduced rates (rates that are lower than what is listed on
the label).
When applying below labeled herbicide rates, growers
must remember that they (the grower or applicator) assume
all the liability for performance. Thus, it is important
to apply reduced rates accurately and timely. The risk of
weed control failure increases as rates are reduced.
Proper application timing is very important when applying
reduced herbicide rates. Postemergence wild oat herbicides
require application to wild oats and crops at precise leaf
stages. Leaf number on wild oats is determined by counting
the leaves on the main stem and disregarding the tillers.
The youngest leaf is counted as a full leaf only when
another leaf becomes visible. Lower leaves, which may have
died from various stresses, such as frost or wind damage,
should also be counted in the total leaf number. An
accurate leaf count is important for optimum wild oat
control. Using reduced-rate herbicides effectively demands
that growers and applicators calibrate their equipment
precisely. There is less margin for application errors
with reduced rates. There are a number of tradeoffs for
the advantages any one wild oat herbicide might offer.
When using reduced herbicide rates, herbicides should be
applied to the smallest labeled wild oat leaf stage.
However, if the herbicide is applied too early, odds are
greater that a late flush of wild oats will require a
second herbicide application, or that some wild oats might
escape treatment.
Most postemergence wild oat herbicides are more
effective when temperatures are cool (less than 75o
F) and when adequate soil moisture is available. The
exception is Avenge – Avenge is more active under hot, dry
conditions. Wild oats also grow better, and with less
stress, when soil and air temperatures are cool (like we
are seeing this year).
Use caution when using reduced herbicide rate for wild
oat control when wild oats are under stress due to high
temperatures (above 75o F), drought, or frost
damage. If wild oat are under environmental stress, the
plants are not growing properly, and will not take up and
transport the herbicide as needed for adequate control.
Research has been conducted for several years at the
Northwest Research and Outreach Center in Crookston,
Minn., to evaluate reduced rates of postemergence wild oat
herbicides. Herbicides were applied at the lowest labeled
rate, ¾ and ½ of the labeled rate in spring wheat and
barley. Results of this research have shown that with
accurate rates and proper timing of application, wild oats
can be controlled with the most effective herbicides at
rates as low as one-half of the normal use rate. In wild
oat populations greater than about 40 plants per square
foot, the full labeled herbicide rate or nearly full rate
gave more consistent wild oat control than the reduced
rates. Under low to moderate wild oat infestation levels,
below 40 wild oat plants per square foot, the reduced
herbicide rates performed very well. However, wild oat
control with reduced herbicide rates can and does vary
from year to year. This is mostly due to environmental
conditions and the wild oat population.
Reduced rates of Puma and Discover have resulted in
good to excellent wild oat control. However, Discover has
given the most consistent wild oat control at the reduced
rate of ¾ and ½ of the labeled rate.
Adoption of reduced herbicide rates for wild oat
control in spring wheat and barley could lead to a savings
of $7 to $13 per acre in chemical costs with grain yields
equal to using full herbicide rates. However, reduced
rates should not be used if:
Wild oats are under stress due to adverse environmental
conditions. Wild oat infestations are greater than 40
plants/ft.
Are Below Labeled Rates
Legal?
A herbicide user can legally choose a rate lower than
listed on the herbicide rate unless the label specifically
prohibits application rates that are less than what is
listed on the label. However, the company has no
obligation to guarantee wild oat control when the
herbicide application rate was less than listed on the
label. Herbicide users should not expect a company
representative to provide any assistance if weed control
is less than expected from a rate of herbicide that is
less than the labeled rate. Thus, the user assumes all
risk and liability of unacceptable weed control when less
than labeled rates are used.
Beverly R. Durgan Weed Scientist,
University of Minnesota

|